The following post, is not aimed at criticising any party for any reason whatsoever. It does not criticise any religion and this post is only aimed at truthfully stating my thoughts respectfully with regard to all parties involved on the matter. Whether you like it or not is NOT my concern.
Lately, read a couple of my fellow uni mates blogs, and they've shared a little about a blogger, who wrote something to her fellow friends in Islam. She blogged about her religious point of view regarding Euphonious. (if you haven't already read a lot of my recent previous posts, Euphonious is a battle of the bands competition, which I've been knocked out off by very very good competition, Felix you should see them dude)
If you'd like to read it, and have the patience to go through something a little long, here're the links
http:danielle.blogspot.com/2007/05/euphonious-2007.html
http://danialle.blogspot.com/2007/03/euphonious-2007-reloaded.html
There are a lot of people who of course are quite unhappy about the follwing posts. It basically just totally discourages anyone from attending the event without feeling condemned by their creator, to know that its a sin to attend such an event, because there's nothing about the event that promotes the culture of the faith, potentially cuts into prayer times, causes you to think in a sinful manner and a lot of other things. At the same time, there are a number of supporters.
One thing that caught my attention a little was that she talked about this all-girl band which happen to be Malay Muslims and, knowing the culture of very open minded Malays, they didn't wear head scarfs (tudung) from wn a manner unacceptable to the faith. There's also mention about how uncontrollable behaviour by spectatorhat I know is in opposition to one of the fundamental beliefs of the Muslim faith. She went on to mention how the lead singer's stage etiquette was unacceptable, apparently the way she moves on stage is is are also illegal. She also mentioned about inappropriate spectator behaviour by which I believe she means, screaming and shouting support which I believe to be a norm at any concert-like event.
Having read that, a lot of people started commenting on her blog and I started to think what I thought about what she said. To be very honest with you, I don't have a comprehensive understanding of the Islamic faith, from what I believe I know, there are a lot of rules to follow, wearing head-scarves is just part of that. Some people have very differing intepretations of what Islam has to say regarding things like this.
From my rough understanding, not very good understanding but a rough one; Islam is very firm in its stands on many areas. The faith has many guidelines for the believers of this faith, and many are the consequences as well for not obeying them. The fact that many guidelines exist have evolved into what I guess are now perceived as rules simply because of the consequences or repercussions. In Malaysia, where more modernised states are undoubtedly influenced more by western media than those that are not, people are generally more open, receptive, and hence tend to compromise.
But about this I am very sure, Islam is very adamant on snuffing out at absolutely any situation for sin to come around the corner. Following that, there are alot of rules, some may call it rigid and has no room for compromise. This is actually the blogger's main point, that there are compromises in the prevention of sin that make this event not halal. She was concerned about Muslims putting themselves intentionally or unintentionally in situations that might cause them to sin.
You see, Islam, in it's pure form does not allow many things or events that are habitually held in our country. The blogger herself mentioned events such as One in a Million and Sure Heboh I think that include performances by Malay female artists that don't 'cover up enough' and so forth. If some guy asks me, "So do you think Euphonious is halal? Bear in mind, I'm not a Muslim, but I would most probably answer, "I'd say... it definitely is not."
Why? Simply because there definitely are these compromises that I believe a pure Muslim would have to make, if he or she wanted to attend. Some don't realise them, some do but close one eye on it. It basically speaks of ignorance.
Even so, I can tell you, that conscientic feeling is not going to stop a lot of people from going. This is what I believe, everything is permissable, not everything is beneficial. Euphonious is simply an event where people get the chance to perform, have fun, listen to music that contains no explicit lyrics which has been specified by the committee. There is nothing wrong with having fun, even the blogger said it herself.
Of course, for me, there's nothing wrong with Euphonious. This is my point of view as a Christian. As for putting yourself in situations that cause you to sin, let me ask you something, have you not been made in the image of God Himself that you should be able to know what is right and what is wrong? Euphonious puts you in a simple situation where you may sit in an auditorium with dimmed lights and perhaps next to a girl or maybe not. Do you not have any self control of your body as not to start getting stupid and thinking dirty stuff about a hot girl sitting next to you? If you do not have this control, I will tell you, you definitely should not go to Euphonious, I can tell you that it's in the bible, but if you do have control, which I truly believe most people have, it's definitely permissable and beneficial to go for Euphonious? Why beneficial? God likes to see His people happy, and I know for sure, music definitely makes people happy.